By skyforbes I've always preferred the Xbox controller. It's fits better in my hands and i'm more accurate with it for FPS and racing games.
The PS5 controller does have an advantage for me when playing third person action and indie games for some reason.
I have medium sized hands with long fingers.
If you prefer the PS5 controller, what size hands and fingers do you have? I'm wondering if people with smaller or larger hands tend toward one or another.