By skyforbes TItles: TGA – The Game Awards / TGJ – The Golden Joystick / BAFTA – British Academy Games Awards / Steam / GDCA – Game Developers Choice Awards / DICE – Design, Innovate, Communicate, Entertain)
Trivia: Baldur's Gate 3 is the only title to win in every award show for its respective year, 2023.
Closest is Elden Ring, which won 5 times (and was nominated again in 2024 for the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion), and Breath of the Wild, which was nominated 4 times (did not win any Steam Game Award, even the "non-specific" ones they did prior to 2018, likely because it's not accessible on Steam), followed by God of War, which also held onto 4 (I have BOTW higher because BOTW won 80% of the awards – GOW only won 66%).
The most disputed years are 2014, 2019, and 2021, all of which had 4 separate winners – though 2014 only had 5 Awards given out.
Several of these games are now among the best selling games of all time (as far as I can verify), including GTAV (2nd), RDR2 (4th), PUBG (6th), TW3:WH (8th), with OW (11th) just out of the Top 10.
The highest Metacritic Score of all winning games is 97 – from Breath of the Wild and Grand Theft Auto 5 – followed directly by both Baldur's Gate 3 and Elden Ring, which both have 96. The lowest is Fortnite with 78, followed by Black Myth: Wukong and Untitled Goose Game, which both have 81.
The best selling game on the list is (obviously) Grand Theft Auto V – the lowest (from what I can find) are Returnal and Hades, both of which have supposedly sold just over 1 million units.
Edit: Added where the wins come from using the acronyms
2013
The Last of Us (3) (BAFTA, GDCA, DICE)
Grand Theft Auto V (1) (TGJ)
2014
Dragon Age: Inquisition (2) (TGA, DICE)
Dark Souls II (1) (TGJ)
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor (1) (GDCA)
Destiny (1) (BAFTA)
2015
The Witcher III: Wild Hunt (3) (TGA, TGJ, GDCA)
Fallout 4 (2) (DICE, BAFTA)
2016
Overwatch (3) (TGA, GDCA, DICE)
Dark Souls III (1) (TGJ)
Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End (1) (BAFTA)
2017
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (4) (TGA, TGJ, GDCA, DICE)
What Remains of Edith Finch (1) (BAFTA)
2018
God of War (4) (TGA, GDCA, DICE, BAFTA)
Fortnite (1) (TGJ)
PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds (1) (Steam)
2019
Untitled Goose Game (2) (GDCA, DICE)
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice (2) (TGA, Steam)
Resident Evil 2 (1) (TGJ)
Outer Wilds (1) (BAFTA)
2020
Hades (3) (GDCA, DICE, BAFTA)
The Last of Us – Part II (2) (TGA, TGJ)
Red Dead Redemption 2 (1) (Steam)
2021
It Takes Two (2) (TGA, DICE)
Resident Evil: Village (2) (TGJ, Steam)
Inscryption (1) (GDCA)
Returnal (1) (BAFTA)
2022
Elden Ring (5) (TGA, TGJ, Steam, GDCA, DICE)
Vampire Survivors (1) (BAFTA)
2023
Baldur’s Gate 3 (6) (Literally Everything)
2024
Astro Bot (3) (TGA, DICE, BAFTA)
Black Myth: Wukong (2) (TGJ, Steam)
Balatro (1) (GDCA)
2025
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (1) (TGJ)