The logic in Arrival (2016) breaks apart when you think about it

It was said that she gained knowledge about the future and about her daughter's illness and chose to do nothing about it. I get that part. But what if she made the other choice. According to the Aliens the future is already set. But she could still make a choice to have her daughter or not. Once she learns about the future she is still giving a choice in the present. This is why I believe the logic of the film falls apart.

Leave a Reply